Wondering how similar they are color-wise.. if anyone has both and can get a pic of them side by side that would be fantastic. TIA!

I have both washes but unfortunately, no way to take a picture. I think Afterhours runs a bit smaller and is a bit heavier in weight.

They are very similar, color-wise; it is night here and they look the same. Will look again in the am and edit with any subtle differences I notice then.

In the light, Afterhours appears a bit grayer while Lagoon is bluer, esp. in the faded areas. Also I think the fade on the Afterhours may be a tad more pronounced. But they are still very, very close.

Both are nice washes, very comfortable and soft.

Hope this helps!

That was very helpful, thanks!