I've had these 2 items for a long time, they were given to me as a gift. I don't want to believe they could be replicas, but you never know. They are the Return to Tiffany round tag bracelet and the oval tag necklace. Tiffany experts: What do you think?

Shizz... These are two tough ones! I'm not sure I will have to think about it a while and do some more comparisons. I have the dog tag necklace at home so when I get home later I can really examine it better.

Something about the fonts and spacing is bothering me. I have to look at it for a while and see if maybe its the angles the pictures were taken or if there really is something off here.

Also, the holes on the dog tag should be directly about the "T" and the "o" and your left hole is a little off the mark I think from this angle...

Where did you get the pieces from? Did you purchase them new or used? How long have you had them? Did they come with boxes and pouches? Is the dog tag curved or flat?

__________________
Wishlist: On a ban. Le sigh. Unless they are R&R padded logos
R&R- Alpha Kurts (30); PADDED LOGOS (29) !!!!!!
SFAM- PF Pink As (30); RCA Flynts -old version (31); Lurex anything all must be long inseams!!

They were given as a gift from a 'posh' friend who I am not friends with any longer. I moved in 2005 after a nasty split and somewhere in the shuffle the bags were lost (among other things!), the boxes I hadn't kept.
The oval tag necklace is slightly curved and every link on the chain is pretty much seamlessly soldered. The clasp is solid and has good movement.
ETA: The links in the necklace are also not completely round, but a *subtle* oval shape.