babyj, i'm a light toned gal myself and peach is actually not that dark...it definitely works best for slightly greenish toned under eye circles...it's not much darker than the multi-tasking concealer. the coloring on the website is not 100% accurate in my opinion.
If anything...you could try it out with a free kit when you make your next order..no harm no foul. I didn't think peach would work for me either because I am fair..but I was totally wrong. I thought sunlight would work for me to correct my circles, but was sadly mistaken...sunlight only made mine more obvious.
HUGE peach color corrector fan here!!!
